Round Table India
You Are Reading
Artificial Intelligence in Education: Opportunities and Challenges for Marginalized Students
3

For An Informed Ambedkar Age

Features

Artificial Intelligence in Education: Opportunities and Challenges for Marginalized Students

on Leave a Comment on Artificial Intelligence in Education: Opportunities and Challenges for Marginalized Students3
tabrez and afroz

Dr. Md Tabrez Alam & Dr Md Afroz

Introduction: Artificial Intelligence (AI) is reshaping the education sector, offering new opportunities for accessibility, personalized learning, and administrative efficiency. However, for marginalized students, AI presents both advantages and challenges. While AI-driven tools can help bridge learning gaps through adaptive learning, language translation, and assistive technologies, structural barriers such as digital inequality, algorithmic biases, and socio-economic disparities continue to limit their impact. This paper critically examines the role of AI in enhancing educational opportunities for marginalized students in India while addressing concerns related to data privacy, caste-based discrimination, and accessibility. It explores how AI can be leveraged to create a more inclusive education system by drawing from secondary sources, case studies, and policy discussions. The author concludes with recommendations for policymakers, educators, and technologists to ensure AI’s ethical and equitable integration into India’s education system.

Methodology: This paper developed an approach through an extensive literature review, focusing on integrating AI into education, particularly for marginalized students in India. It examines secondary data sources, including academic articles, reports, government publications, and case studies from global and Indian contexts. The research method is designed to explore AI’s potential to reduce educational disparities while critically analyzing its ethical, infrastructural, and accessibility challenges. It is structured around key themes such as AI-driven personalized learning, overcoming linguistic and accessibility barriers, AI’s impact on marginalized communities, and algorithmic biases in AI systems. It draws upon reports from UNESCO, KPMG, and Stanford Law School, among others, to assess global best practices and their applicability to the Indian education system.

AI’s Transformative Role in Indian Education: 

Despite the challenges, AI holds the potential to revolutionize education in India. By addressing the digital divide and enhancing digital literacy, AI can empower marginalized students and create a more inclusive educational framework. AI is revolutionizing educational practices in India, introducing innovations that tailor learning, enhance accessibility, and automate administrative tasks. AI-driven tools, such as adaptive learning platforms and language translation technologies, offer promising solutions to the challenges faced by India’s diverse student population. These advancements have the potential to improve learning outcomes and student engagement significantly. However, it’s important to acknowledge that these advancements bring ethical concerns, algorithmic biases, and digital access disparities to light, particularly for marginalized communities. AI-powered educational interventions have shown significant potential in bridging learning gaps for students in remote and underprivileged areas. India Today report (2024), AI-enabled platforms have contributed to reducing dropout rates and improving student engagement in underserved regions. However, access to such technologies remains unequal, with only 40% of rural India having reliable internet access (TRAI & NSS Reports). Without adequate infrastructure, AI-driven learning solutions risk reinforcing existing educational inequalities rather than mitigating them.

AI’s influence extends beyond accessibility to assessment and content delivery, raising significant ethical concerns. Research, such as that published in Nature Humanities and Social Sciences Communications (2024), suggests that AI-powered grading systems and content curation tools often reflect biases in their training datasets. This disproportionately affects marginalized students who may not fit the ‘ideal’ AI-generated learning profile. Furthermore, the prevalence of English and urban-centric knowledge bases in AI-powered learning platforms limits their effectiveness for students from non-dominant linguistic and socio-economic backgrounds.

Moreover, AI has transformed medical and health education, allowing students to use AI-powered diagnostic training and real-time simulations (PubMed Central, 2024). However, concerns over data privacy and the ethical implications of AI replacing human-led instruction remain significant challenges. A report from Stanford Law School (2024) highlights how AI-driven education technologies have widened racial disparities in learning outcomes, a phenomenon that mirrors caste-based educational disadvantages in India. This underscores the need to develop and implement inclusive AI models recognizing socio-cultural and linguistic diversity.

Barriers to AI Accessibility for Marginalized Students

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has the potential to revolutionize education, but for marginalized students in India, the persistent digital divide remains a formidable barrier. The UDISE+ 2023-24 report indicates that only 57.2% of schools have functional computers, and only 53.9% have internet access. This limited infrastructure, coupled with the fact that less than one-third of youth aged 15-29 possess basic internet skills, underscores the urgent need to address the challenges faced by disadvantaged students in leveraging AI-driven learning tools. The Digital India programme, launched in 2015, was a significant step towards bridging the digital divide in India. It aimed to provide digital infrastructure, affordable internet access, and digital literacy programs, particularly in rural and economically disadvantaged areas. However, infrastructure deficits and socio-economic disparities have hindered the programme’s progress. A 2021 GSMA survey found that women in India are 41% less likely than men to use mobile internet, and despite 94% of villages having mobile network coverage, service quality remains a challenge. These barriers make it difficult for marginalized students to access AI-powered education solutions, reinforcing existing inequalities instead of mitigating them. Without substantial investments in rural digital infrastructure, affordable internet access, and digital literacy programs, AI in education may inadvertently exclude those who need it most, widening the educational divide rather than closing it.

 Limited Digital Infrastructure: A critical challenge in AI-based education is the lack of adequate digital infrastructure in rural and economically disadvantaged areas. According to the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI), as of 2024, internet penetration in rural India remains below 40%, significantly lower than in urban areas. Without high-speed internet and reliable electricity, students from these regions struggle to access AI-driven educational tools. This infrastructural gap exacerbates educational inequalities and limits students’ ability to use AI-enhanced learning platforms. 

Affordability of AI Tools and Devices: The cost of AI-powered educational tools remains prohibitively high for many low-income families. While government initiatives such as the Digital India campaign aim to provide affordable digital access, the financial burden of purchasing AI-enabled devices, including tablets, smartphones, and laptops, continues to be challenging. Additionally, subscription fees for AI-based learning platforms create further economic barriers, preventing students from marginalized backgrounds from benefiting from these technologies.

Lack of AI Literacy and Digital Skills: For AI-based education to be effective, students and teachers must have a basic understanding of digital tools and AI functionalities. Unfortunately, AI literacy remains low among marginalized communities due to inadequate training programs and limited exposure to technology. A study by UNESCO (2024) highlights that the digital literacy rate in rural India is significantly lower than in urban centres, hindering students’ ability to utilize AI-powered learning resources effectively. 

Language and Content Biases in AI Systems: Most AI-driven educational platforms are developed using data representing urban, English-speaking populations. This creates challenges for students from non-English-speaking and Indigenous backgrounds who may find AI-generated content less relevant or challenging to comprehend. AI translation tools, though improving, still struggle with regional dialects and cultural nuances, making educational content less inclusive.

AI and Social Equity: Caste, Identity, and Education

AI is reshaping education, offering new opportunities for marginalized students while reinforcing structural inequalities. This section explores how AI interacts with caste, identity, and social equity in Indian education. While AI-driven tools have the potential to bridge educational gaps, concerns regarding accessibility, algorithmic bias, and digital discrimination remain significant. Drawing from academic literature and policy reports, the section examines the role of AI in reinforcing or mitigating disparities based on caste and socio-economic identity. AI in education is often promoted as a tool for democratizing learning, enabling students from diverse socio-economic backgrounds to access high-quality education. However, in India, where caste and social stratification still define access to resources, AI risks perpetuating existing inequalities. Internet penetration, digital literacy, and infrastructural limitations further exacerbate these challenges, preventing marginalized students from fully benefiting from AI-enhanced learning. This section critically assesses how caste and identity shape AI accessibility and educational outcomes.

Despite the increasing integration of artificial intelligence (AI) in education, marginalized students in India struggle with accessibility due to the persistent digital divide. According to TRAI and NSS reports, internet penetration in rural areas remains below 40%, severely limiting the ability of Scheduled Castes (SCs), Scheduled Tribes (STs), and Other Backward Classes (OBCs) to engage with AI-powered learning tools. AI-driven educational platforms, which require stable internet and digital literacy, risk widening the existing inequalities rather than bridging them. Furthermore, AI-powered assessments tend to favour students with better access to technology, as a 2024 study in the Journal of Social Sciences Review found that students from under-resourced schools are disadvantaged by standardized AI algorithms that fail to account for their socio-economic challenges. Without targeted interventions, AI in education may reinforce systemic disparities rather than provide inclusive learning opportunities. Beyond accessibility, AI models also risk perpetuating social biases, particularly caste discrimination, in educational content and assessments. Research from Round Table India (2024) highlights that AI-generated study materials often lack representation from Dalit, Adivasi, and other marginalized voices, with content predominantly aligning with upper-caste narratives. Additionally, facial recognition and natural language processing tools have been found to favour urban dialects and dominant linguistic patterns, excluding students from vernacular and Indigenous backgrounds. Reports from India Today Best Colleges (2024) further indicate that generative AI in education tends to reproduce existing caste-based knowledge hierarchies rather than challenge them. If AI is to serve as an equalizing force in education, it must be critically examined and diversified to reflect India’s socio-cultural plurality.

Ethical and Data Privacy Concerns in AI-Driven Education

Integrating artificial intelligence (AI) in education brings opportunities and challenges for marginalized students, particularly concerning data privacy and algorithmic bias. AI-driven learning platforms rely on extensive student data collection to personalize learning experiences and automate assessments. However, without stringent data protection policies, marginalized students—already vulnerable to systemic inequities—face additional risks of surveillance, data breaches, and unauthorized use of personal information (Nature Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 2024). Furthermore, AI-based grading systems, trained on historical datasets, often inherit socio-economic biases, leading to unfair academic evaluations. A study published in the Journal of Social Sciences Review (2024) found that automated grading disproportionately disadvantages students from underprivileged backgrounds, reinforcing existing educational inequalities instead of mitigating them. These biases remain unaddressed without transparency and accountability in AI decision-making, limiting AI’s potential as an inclusive learning tool.

Conclusion: Artificial Intelligence (AI) has the potential to revolutionize education by making learning more accessible, personalized, and adaptive. However, its deployment in marginalized communities presents significant challenges, including inadequate digital infrastructure, socio-economic disparities, and algorithmic biases. While AI-driven tools can enhance language accessibility, support students with disabilities, and offer innovative learning methodologies, the digital divide hinders equitable access. To ensure AI serves as a tool for educational equity, policymakers must focus on expanding internet connectivity, integrating AI literacy programs for educators and students, and ensuring AI-driven assessments are unbiased and contextually relevant. Collaborative efforts between government bodies, private stakeholders, and academic institutions are essential to develop inclusive AI models that address linguistic, cultural, and socio-economic diversity.

Furthermore, ethical concerns related to data privacy, surveillance, and the reinforcement of caste and identity-based discrimination must be systematically addressed through robust regulatory frameworks. AI systems should undergo regular bias audits to prevent discriminatory outcomes, and AI-generated educational content must incorporate vernacular and indigenous knowledge to ensure inclusivity. Policy initiatives should prioritize digital access for marginalized communities, promote fairness in AI applications, and establish targeted AI training programs for underprivileged students. A multi-stakeholder approach—bringing together policymakers, educators, researchers, and technology developers—is necessary to ensure AI-driven education is ethical, inclusive, and equitable. By addressing these challenges, AI can become a powerful instrument for social mobility and educational justice, enabling marginalized students to overcome systemic barriers and access quality education.

References 

~~~

Dr Md Afroz, Researcher/Author & faculty in the Department of Political Science, (MANUU), Hyderabad.  He has penned articles in Journals, research papers, and his upcoming books are “Bridging Divides: Federalism in Theory and Practice” and “Comparative Government and Politics in the Digital Age,” which capture the new age politics. He can be contacted @ Email: afrozjamia@gmail.com. X Tweets: @khwajaafrozsidd

Dr. Md Tabrez Alam, Consultant at the Centre for Child Rights-NUSRL, Ranchi. He earned MSW/MPhil/PhD in Social Work, is a co-founder of Social Works Collectives, and an Associate at Rising Tree Foundation. His research/work areas are discrimination, segregation, inclusion, and development policy advocacy. He can be contacted @ Email: ktabrezshams@gmail.com X tweets: @ktabrezshams

 

You may also like...

Popular Articles...

Leave a Reply